The Senate is expected to vote soon on its updated version of the reconciliation bill, a sprawling effort to cut spending, extend the 2017 tax cuts, reform health care, increase border and defense funding, and deliver on many of President Trump’s campaign promises.
This Tax Tracker provides a reading list of relevant articles and analysis on many of the most significant tax policy changes in the House and Senate tax bills. It starts with some of the major economic and budgetary estimates so far, then includes links to diverse views on 14 major categories of changes in the bills.
Overall, the Senate version of the bill is significantly more pro-growth than what the House passed. It achieves additional economic growth by permanently extending expensing and other business investment tax cuts. The House bill includes a more aggressive repeal of the Inflation Reduction Act green subsidies, a bright spot in rolling back distortionary special interest provisions. Both versions of the bill include dozens of other new and expanded tax subsidies, credits, and deductions that will increase complexity, open new avenues for tax avoidance, and deliver little long-term growth.
The final pieces of the Senate version of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA) are still falling into place, and the parliamentarian has ruled some provisions (in their current form) do not comply with the Byrd Rule.
My side-by-side comparison of the House-passed and Senate draft is here. Tax Notes has a similar feature.
The Senate tax bill text is here (from June 16), and the Finance Committee section-by-section summary is here. The Joint Committee on Taxation (JCT) section-by-section summary of the House bill is here.
Revenue and Deficits
The JCT released three revenue scores of the bill. It estimates the House bill would lower revenue by $3.8 trillion over 10 years from the conventional current law baseline. The Senate bill is estimated to reduce revenue by $442 billion from a current policy baseline and $4.2 trillion from a current law baseline. The figure below, by the Bipartisan Policy Center’s Andrew Lautz, shows a side-by-side comparison of the revenue estimates by major provisions.
Because both the House and Senate include many temporary tax cuts (but more so in the House), the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget (CRFB) estimates that, if made permanent, the revenue reductions from the House tax cuts would increase to $5.2 trillion and the Senate would increase to $4.8 trillion over 10 years.
Including the spending changes, the Congressional Budget Office estimates that the House bill increases primary (non-interest) deficits by $2.4 trillion. CRFB estimates the Senate bill is likely to add between $3.5 and $4.2 trillion to the debt (including interest). The full score of the Senate bill will be released after the bill text is final.
Economic Growth
Eight government and independent organizations have released “dynamic scores” of OBBBA, assessing its impact on the economy and changes in revenue due to the macroeconomic feedback. These complex models rely on strong (and different) assumptions and vary significantly in what they include and exclude. The consensus estimates show that both versions of the bill are pro-growth, but neither bill will generate enough dynamic revenue to offset the size of the tax cuts.
The table below summarizes the economic and dynamic revenue estimates. The estimates of the House bill show smaller economic impacts because many of the most pro-growth provisions, such as business expensing, are temporary. And thus, the Senate scores show larger economic effects because more of the bill is permanent. The models that include stronger assumptions about the negative economic and budgetary effects of additional debt tend to also have smaller (or negative) economic and revenue effects. Those with larger effects tend to assume workers and investors are more responsive to tax changes. The Council of Economic Advisers' estimate is an outlier; this is primarily because it leaves out some of the base broadening tax increases and offsetting spending cuts.
Resources on Major Provisions
A reading list for major changes and how they are treated in the two versions of the bill.
High-Level Summaries: good, bad, and areas for improvement
House “One Big Beautiful Bill” Riddled with Temporary Tax Policy, Erica York
The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly in the Senate Finance’s “One Big Beautiful Bill,” Daniel Bunn, Alex Muresianu, William McBride
How the Senate Can Fix the Big Beautiful Mess, Jack Salmon
Republicans’ One, Big, Beautiful Tax Bill Needs a Makeover, Adam Michel
Individual State and Local Tax Deduction (SALT) and Itemized Deduction Limits
Proposed SALT Cap Increase Is An Expensive Boost For Few Communities, Nikhita Airi
SALT Subsidies Are Crowding Out Positive Tax Reforms in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (House), Preston Brashers, Brian O'Quinn
A New (and Better) Limitation on Itemized Deductions (House), Kyle Pomerleau
Business Pass-Through Deduction (199A) and Pass-Through SALT Limits
How Does the House-Passed Tax Bill Change the Section 199A Pass-Through Deduction? Erica York
House Tax Bill Would Worsen Business Tax Parity, Kyle Pomerleau
SALT Cap Workarounds for Some Pass-Through Entities Are Threatened by One, Big, Beautiful Bill (House), Andrey Yushkov, Jared Walczak
Senate Softens Blow for Pass-Throughs Using Current SALT Workarounds, Jared Walczak
The Next Tax Reform Glitch Is Coming to Main Street Businesses, Ryan Ellis
Republicans Clamp Down on SALT Workaround for Business Owners, Richard Rubin
Inflation Reduction Act Green Energy Credits
Repealing IRA Energy Credits: Senate Proposal, Shuting Pomerleau
How the IRA Provisions (and Scores) Have Changed, Alex Muresianu
Senate Bill Would Slow Phaseout of Some Energy Tax Credits, Katie Lobosco
The House Drew the Line on Green Cronyism — the Senate Better Not Cross It, Adam Michel
International Tax Reform
The Senate Finance Committee’s New International Tax Package: A First Look, Alan Cole
Senate GOP Opts for International Tax Regime Redesign, Jonathan Curry
The New Retaliation Tax, Section 899, Adam Michel (recently dropped)
Structures Deduction
House Budget Bill Would Lower Taxes for Some US Manufacturers, Thomas Brosy
The CREATE JOBS Act: A Pro-Growth and Fiscally Responsible Tax Proposal, Tyler Parks
Remittance Tax
The Remittances Tax: High Paperwork, Low Payoff, Alan Cole, Patrick Dunn
Congress Should Not Impose Capital Controls, Stan Veuger, Kyle Pomerleau
Trump Accounts
‘Trump Accounts’ Could Be Better. Here’s How. Alex Muresianu, Sam Cluggish
Swap “Trump Accounts” for USAs, Adam Michel
Enhanced Senior Deduction
How Would the Proposed Additional Senior Deduction Compare to No Tax on Social Security? Alex Durante
Trump Pledged ‘No Tax on Social Security.’ The Tax Bill Says Otherwise, Ashlea Ebeling, Richard Rubin
Domestic Car Loan Deduction
Car Loan Deductibility—A Misguided Solution to Rising Delinquency Rates, Andrew Wilford
Trump Proposes Bringing Back the Deduction for Auto Loan Interest, Alex Brill, Kyle Pomerleau, Stan Veuger
Education: Student Loans, Scholarship Granting Organizations, and 529s
The Tax Bill Would Deliver a Big Win for Private Schools—and Investors, Matt Barnum, Richard Rubin
OBBBA Would Extend A Student Loan Tax Break That Only Benefits The Best-Off Borrowers, Adam Looney
Four Reasons School Choice Is Good, but Federal Is Bad, Neal McCluskey
Why a Federal Tax-Credit Scholarship Program Will Not Advance School Choice in America, Lindsey Burke, Adam Michel
Endowment Tax, Foundation Tax, and Charitable Giving
Why Universities Shouldn’t Get Better Tax Treatment Than Retirees, Scott Hodge
A College Endowment Tax Is the Wrong Federal Policy, Neal McCluskey
The OBBBA Higher Education Endowment Tax Could Divert Colleges From Their Core Mission And Encourage Tax Sheltering, C. Eugene Steuerle, Sandy Baum, Jill S. Manny
Foundation Tax Punishes Good Deeds, Debbie Jennings, Tyler Martinez
One Big, Beautiful Bill Complicates Charitable Giving, Robert McClelland, Elena Spatoulas Patel
Place-Based Subsidies: Opportunity Zones and New Markets Tax Credit
Opportunity Zones: A Tax Break That Missed Its Target, Public Finance Team
Congress Should Let the New Markets Tax Credit Expire, Adam Michel
Health Savings Accounts
Why Is Congress Abandoning One of the Best Health Insurance Reforms in a Generation? Ryan Ellis
House Republicans’ Reconciliation Bills Are Derelict on Health Reform, Michael F. Cannon
Health Care Provisions in the One Big Beautiful Bill: Reducing Waste, Fraud, and Abuse While Empowering American Patients (House), Brian Blase, Ryan Long, Gabrielle Kalisz, Niklas Kleinworth